Community Set: Recent Activity
| Community Set: Cardlist | Visual spoiler | Export | Booster | Comments | Search | Recent activity |
| Mechanics | Skeleton | Common Breakdown Ref | All commons for playtesting |
Recent updates to Community Set: (Generated at 2025-12-19 21:19:38)
hexproof -> pay-(2)-to-target
Good point, it needs balancing and retemplating.
That's a good option. We should figure out whether the number of monocolour vanillas will leave us wanting some gold vanillas (well, flying vanillas, which is the most minimal french vanilla possible), and so whether to stick with Carer of Cloth and Water. But this is a more feasible possibility if it takes more mana to mess with. And perfect for the colours: taxing is typically a white ability, but Frost Titan is a powerful drag to make it blue.
Thanks :)
Again, not sure of cost, size of effect or speed, but it makes sense in this Aer/non-Aer set.
Hmm, one other benefit to putting this on a green creature is that the one iconic green flying creature is Birds of Paradise, and this could feel like a homage to that.
Yeah. I originally had "raise dead", but I thought the flavour was better if it was A->B->C. But it could equally well be "Ascend to the clouds. Return target creature card in a graveyard and target creature to their owner's hands".
this might be a good set for the Generated card
Sorcery, Return target permanent card from your graveyard to the battlefield.
Oh yes, that does look good. Simple, but strong and appropriate. Can we call it "unvindicate"? :)
I think it's good to play with variants on gain flying and lose flying to see where they might be good, but for now I think we should just assume that RG gets flying by default and doesn't need a hack (after all, there'll be several RG creatures, they can't all be nearly-flying)?
Oh nice. Yes, it's obvious, but it's also not something that I'd thought of; and "obvious in retrospect" is a great quality for a card :)
Hmm. Yes. Reminds me of Countersquall. Which is pretty much precisely what Jack describes in his last paragraph :)
Not quite sure what "fights any number of target creatures" is meant to do. Deals its power in damage to each of them is crazy-powerful. Deals total damage equal to its power divided as you choose among them is plausible, but certainly not in the rules.
Heh. It's like Soul Manipulation, or Soulquake, or Rise // Fall. But those are all Raise Dead rather than Zombify.
We definitely could do this. Although actually, maybe this might be a good set for the Generated card
Sorcery, Return target permanent card from your graveyard to the battlefield.
@V: Hahaha, fantastic :)
@Link: That's Thermalmancer. Could do. I'm not very keen on that idea, but it's an option.
Yeah, I'm not really trying to balance cards this afternoon, just look for ideas that may be worth doing.
Looking at recent examples, it should probably be "your graveyard", and then the cost for that is, I suspect "the effect is worth about 3B or 3W but the card should never cost less than 5 CMC to prevent too-powerful reanimation decks". And I think "unsummon" costs at most U. 3B + U could probably be 2BU, but this card should probably be at least 3BU.
Reanimate but with an attached unsummon rather than a lifeloss?
Probably slightly undercosted, yeah - though amusingly can't be used after a wrath because there's no target for the second half :)
It's certainly a nice flavor, since the five monocolor factions are fighting together but don't really get along.
Hulk smash!
(Probably should be simplified.)
This seems quite powerful for the cost, doesn't it? Maybe I'm wrong.
This is basically Challenge from Sienara's Facets/Clockwork Wings. I was thinking what spells could be interesting as multicolored, and one was specific counterspells.
This may be better if it cost more, only hit some large subset of spells, but had some other bonus as well?
An obvious variation of Agony Warp. We probably don't want to do a whole cycle of these, but there may be some combination which is useful.
"Target a different creature for each colour of mana that land could produce, and deal 2 damage to them."
An attempt to tie land destruction to a small burn spell.
It's still not quite right, ideally it would: target any land; do damage to a creature of the appropriate color; get better the more different colors people are playing. Any suggestions?
Colored artifacts? Evil? :(