Melody: Recent Activity
| Melody: Cardlist | Visual spoiler | Export | Booster | Comments | Search | Recent activity |
| Mechanics | Skeleton | White Commons | Blue Commons | Black Commons | Red Commons | Green Commons | Multicolor Commons | Artifact Commons |
Recent updates to Melody: (Generated at 2026-01-30 22:01:34)
It is a white effect (Reprisal, Intrepid Hero, Radiant's Judgment, Topple), but black got it in Planar Chaos with Big Game Hunter. It looks fine to me.
I'm worried it looks a bit too white with this form of restriction, but it's a good place to start.
Hilarious flavour :)
Oh, good idea. It's still situational, but stands a much higher chance of hitting a creature they cared about; if you're lucky one with protection from black.
Upped it to
to ease my conscience, and let people curve out on Imps.
I can understand what you're saying, but I feel like the player in control of the Fiend will probably make sure to point out all the damage as it happens. Nonetheless, it may be an inappropriate Rhythm-hoser if it just adds to the "fiddly-ness" of the mechanic.
While I think there are some templating solutions that could be used to avoid it, I feel it's a type of risk that helps cement this in red.
I think this may get very confusing in play. Imagine an X/2 with a tap ability, perhaps a pinger that costs mana to use. I've been using it some turns but not others. Start of my turn, I untap a bunch of guys, and they each take 1 damage. I cast a couple of spells, then declare an attack, which gets complicated with combat tricks. I decide to use my pinger, and the question now is "Has that guy already taken damage this turn?" The answer depends on whether I untapped him way back at the start of this turn... i.e. whether I tapped him last turn. That could often be a long time ago, too long to remember.
With careful bookkeeping it won't be an issue, but not every player is completely careful with their bookkeeping all the time.
Interesting idea! It's somewhat of a pity that it is on your side long enough to kill your X/1s. But that's pretty hard to avoid.
Added "at random" to discard; it is a hymn after all.