Multiverse: Ulgrotha: Darkness Falls Forever: Recent Activity

2013-02-27 04:46:09: jmgariepy commented on Standfast Orders

Agreed. The card seriously jumped in playability.

2013-02-27 01:07:03: Alex commented on Standfast Orders

Yay for revisiting the Masako the Humorless ability.

2013-02-26 15:22:50: aether_tech commented on Voice's Favor

Everyone likes it when "indestructible" is included somewhere in a set.

2013-02-26 15:22:15: aether_tech commented on Stone Protectors

Hmmm, how about 3/6?

2013-02-26 15:21:54: aether_tech edited Standfast Orders

2013-02-26 15:21:26: aether_tech edited Standfast Orders

2013-02-26 15:21:17: aether_tech commented on Standfast Orders

Hmm, good point. I'll fix that issue up. As for this card...hmm.

removed the part about black creatures.

2013-02-26 15:20:29: aether_tech edited Soraya's Falcon

2013-02-26 15:20:24: aether_tech commented on Soraya's Falcon

I guess I could make it a 3/2, it does have first strike.

2013-02-26 15:19:47: aether_tech commented on Shieldspell

Changed it to +4, thanks for pointing out shield mate exists jmpariepy!

2013-02-26 15:19:33: aether_tech edited Shieldspell

2013-02-26 15:19:06: aether_tech commented on Shelter

I feel like Aura Blast is just some what bad, even for a set like this.

2013-02-26 15:18:20: aether_tech commented on Knight of the Order of Soul's Rest

needs a better name, but the idea is that a creature killed by the knights of this...order/group have their souls "purified" (to borrow the term from anime,) and can't be resurrected (easily.)

2013-02-26 15:17:33: aether_tech edited Knight of the Order of Soul's Rest

2013-02-26 15:15:55: aether_tech commented on Knight of the Order of Soul's Rest

Hmm... Fixing...

2013-02-26 14:00:53: jmgariepy commented on Knight of the Order of Soul's Rest

For the record, this would be the 9th white card that either harshes on black, or vampires. To me, 3 cards would have been excessive, but might have gotten a point across. Nine just seems silly. For comparison's sake, Homelands only had 3 white anti-black cards: Death Speakers, Rashka the Slayer and Serra Inquisitor.

2013-02-26 13:56:19: jmgariepy commented on Voice's Favor

'Indestructible' is an odd word for this set. I'm not sure how I feel about it. I don't really have a problem with the idea if that's what was needed to get the job done... but I almost feel like this card should prevent all damage or something. Ah well. I guess that's a personal taste issue.

2013-02-26 13:53:07: jmgariepy commented on Stone Protectors

Personally, I'd bump this to a 4/5 to help make up the difference. But I guess it doesn't really need it. Odd power level problem is odd. This card is clearly much too powerful for common, but is very underwhelming at uncommon. Strange that.

2013-02-26 13:46:51: jmgariepy commented on Standfast Orders

So... when I block, I make my creatures worse? Because that's mostly what I read when I see this card... I'd rather not have it on the battlefield in the first place. I definitely would not like to dedicate a slot to it.

I'm pretty aware that that's not how the card works, and that there are plenty of match-ups and decks where this card is great. As far as first impressions go, though, this card is kind of poopy. Maybe the bonus should be greater and the card more expensive? It would also give players a reason to build around this card... you know... because you could always just play Crusade instead.

Oh, also, I'm just going through your white cards today, but what's with all the black hate? White doesn't hate red ever? Because I think I've seen four anti-white black cards so far, but Hazduur seems to be cool with Joven and Chandler hanging around the abbey.

2013-02-26 13:45:43: Vitenka commented on Shieldspell

Um wow; this is strictly worse than Healing Salve. You'd get a lot of hate, methinks.

(Ok, it's not quite strictly worse; P/T inversion exists, which gives this an interesting corner case. But still.)

2013-02-26 13:41:08: jmgariepy commented on Soraya's Falcon

Surprisingly good compared to the rest of the set... or Thunder Spirit for that matter. I know you're looking forward to draft more, but if this card appeared in constructed, in would overshadow all the other white cards.

2013-02-26 13:39:07: jmgariepy commented on Shieldspell

I feel kind of wrong for wanting WotC to print this 'bad' spell. It would be nice, though, I assume Shield Mate's +0/+4 is a more likely number.

2013-02-26 13:36:30: jmgariepy commented on Shelter

Hey! Reprint from Odyssey coming through!

It's a good choice, but if you're already doing a non-Homelands reprint, may I instead suggest Aura Blast? You know... because Daria is a character for Homelands, but she's mysteriously showed up in Planeshift for some reason.

2013-02-26 13:27:23: jmgariepy commented on Holy Armorer

I know the power level of this set is low, but I got to admit this is pretty unexciting. I don't expect this card to suddenly be as good as Celestial Crusader or Wizened Cenn, but, failing that, it should at least be quirky. A card like this just invites poor comparisons. Maybe we can give Knights the Order of Leitbur activated abilities? that is, assuming you aren't using them somewhere else?

2013-02-26 12:03:29: Vitenka commented on Aliban's Talisman

More flexible, but also more painful Talisman of Impulse? Nice. I'd certainly want lots of them, but probably wouldn't put them in every deck.

2013-02-26 05:22:31: aether_tech commented on the cardset Ulgrotha: Darkness Falls Forever

Still looking for more willing eyes to critique the set.

2013-02-21 00:50:14: aether_tech commented on the cardset Ulgrotha: Darkness Falls Forever

Ok, I've updated the last couple of cards with issues, let me know what you all think.

(also, thanks for taking a look at giving me your input.)

2013-02-20 20:18:32: aether_tech edited Reveka's Student

2013-02-20 20:18:19: aether_tech edited Aliban's Talisman

2013-02-20 20:18:03: aether_tech edited Blessing of Serra