Fascinating. I like it. We had a big discussion over on Journeyman Falconwright whether a 2/2 for that made a 1/1 flying token was too good; I think the 1/1 is more sensible.
I think so, if only to avoid the rules trickiness of what happens if you do it targeting your own attacking creatures. "target creature attacking you" was how Flash Foliage did it.
BTW, I fear the ability is extremely strong. The flow of the card suggests using it on the Spirit token, but it's more likely to be used on your random 4/1s or whatever. Which may be just what you're after, on a 4-mana 2/2 legend, but just letting you know.
Pity the unkicked version is so uninspiring, but for a cantrip 1/1 flyer sounds about right. (Compared with Sea Gate Oracle and Messenger Falcons, whose name I've only just realised is a reference to Carrier Pigeons.)
I could have just recycled the Alara cycle of Seaside Citadel and friends, but personally I think enemy lands should be more difficult than ally lands. That's why I somewhat disagree with the Isolated Chapel cycle in Innistrad (even though I'm glad they were printed).
Fascinating. I like it. We had a big discussion over on Journeyman Falconwright whether a 2/2 for
that made a 1/1 flying token was too good; I think the 1/1 is more sensible.
I think so, if only to avoid the rules trickiness of what happens if you do it targeting your own attacking creatures. "target creature attacking you" was how Flash Foliage did it.
BTW, I fear the
ability is extremely strong. The flow of the card suggests using it on the Spirit token, but it's more likely to be used on your random 4/1s or whatever. Which may be just what you're after, on a 4-mana 2/2 legend, but just letting you know.
Nice design. Could obviously sit in red as much as in white, but fine in either.
Very odd card. I think I like it.
I'm glad the move feature, with its preservation of comments, has proved useful :)
Yee-ee-ow. Oblivion Ring but with the evil blinky shenanigans built-in. Why bother with the "return" clause when it'll always be circumvented?
Wow. Probably. I think it's good as it is. This reminds me of Ceaseless Searblades.
You could try to instate a tradition via this set of Knight Clerics?
It's... odd. I don't think +5/+0 and lose defender is good enough for 7 mana of 3 colours, though; compare Titanic Ultimatum.
Pity the unkicked version is so uninspiring, but
for a cantrip 1/1 flyer sounds about right. (Compared with Sea Gate Oracle and Messenger Falcons, whose name I've only just realised is a reference to Carrier Pigeons.)
I could have just recycled the Alara cycle of Seaside Citadel and friends, but personally I think enemy lands should be more difficult than ally lands. That's why I somewhat disagree with the Isolated Chapel cycle in Innistrad (even though I'm glad they were printed).
I know it's weird that this is the only card with art, but I stumbled on this photo and it was just so perfect for the card I couldn't resist.
I think the power level needs to be tested, but the basic idea is clear.
Could this be worded more succinctly?
Like Elyssgate Guardian, I feel he might need more support within the set.
I don't know about the costs on this.
This is probably too good, but I don't know. Should it cost less, so that it doesn't benefit itself so much?