For Challenge # 035. The rule I'm changing in Magic right now is "What if card text shut off when a permanent is tapped?". Evidently, we get a Dwarf that is customed tailored to take down a Grizzly Bears enchanted with Serra's Embrace
You know, that's a good question. I assume that if they continued to make the rules do this, then they came up with their own wacky justification to take care of all this. So let's say this: Keyword abilities aren't effected, just rules text. That gives us some really weird interactions. A creature with First Strike still has first strike on the attack. If, however, that creature read "This creature has first strike", it loses it. Man, those fictional developers were real maroons, eh?
Actually, that's producing just the right kind of complexity, I think.
You could also assume "Enchant Creature" acts like "Summon Creature" or "Flash" - it happens, and then it's done and doesn't matter if it goes away. That would also fix the problem, but with less ensuing strangeness.
For Challenge # 035. The rule I'm changing in Magic right now is "What if card text shut off when a permanent is tapped?". Evidently, we get a Dwarf that is customed tailored to take down a Grizzly Bears enchanted with Serra's Embrace
Will that also get rid of the enchant ability, putting the Aura into its owner's graveyard?
You know, that's a good question. I assume that if they continued to make the rules do this, then they came up with their own wacky justification to take care of all this. So let's say this: Keyword abilities aren't effected, just rules text. That gives us some really weird interactions. A creature with First Strike still has first strike on the attack. If, however, that creature read "This creature has first strike", it loses it. Man, those fictional developers were real maroons, eh?
Actually, that's producing just the right kind of complexity, I think. You could also assume "Enchant Creature" acts like "Summon Creature" or "Flash" - it happens, and then it's done and doesn't matter if it goes away. That would also fix the problem, but with less ensuing strangeness.