Yeah. It's nice; but not overpowering. That feels about right to me.
Has some slightly interesting play options too. Opponent blocks the creature that isn't equipped with it; so after combat move it and then kill that creature to exile.
But "dead" and "exiled" is usually a very small difference, so it should be ok to allow such shenanigans.
Indeed. I mean, I'm looking at this and thinking "Wow, annihilate at least let you sacc land" (it also didn't give you a chance to block first; so they're comparably powerful)
An argument can be made against this card being a common. Not because the card is too powerful... it could cost and and the problem would still be there... it's how a card like this would completely warp the draft environment. If I knew this existed in a draft, I would draft nothing but evasive creatures as often as I possibly could. A lot of drafts, then, would become "How many Spiked Clubs did you draft?" and "How well can you block evasive creatures?"
0-power critters won't do much, since they don't count as "dealing combat damage" if they deal 0.
This seems fine. Most mill-themed one-drops don't do much (Merrow Witsniper anyone?). This at least has potential to be useful against people gaining lots of life, or hiding behind Worship.
Seems better to me. If you end up wanting to really push this you could try it at , but I'd say stick at unless you have a need to make it much better.
Um. I don't think you mean Brainstorm. Braingeyser, maybe?
Well, taking the usual
->
this still costs one more in order to cantrip. So I guess it's fair.
Somewhat terrifying mill compared to, say, Brainstorm though; considering the cost and downside on that one.
Yes, this seems fine as a minor bonus on a Bonesplitter-plus-
.
Heh. Well, I guess Glimpse the Unthinkable has been pretty much obsoleted these days anyway. Fair enough.
Hmm. The ability from Frostwielder.
Yeah. It's nice; but not overpowering. That feels about right to me.
Has some slightly interesting play options too. Opponent blocks the creature that isn't equipped with it; so after combat move it and then kill that creature to exile.
But "dead" and "exiled" is usually a very small difference, so it should be ok to allow such shenanigans.
How's it now?
Hmm. Yeah, I think a repeatable card advantage ability isn't "minor" enough for common.
(The only card that grants annihilator is Eldrazi Conscription, which was somewhat format-warping itself in combination with Sovereigns of Lost Alara.)
Indeed. I mean, I'm looking at this and thinking "Wow, annihilate at least let you sacc land" (it also didn't give you a chance to block first; so they're comparably powerful)
I can't find ANY equipment granting annihilate.
An argument can be made against this card being a common. Not because the card is too powerful... it could cost
and 
and the problem would still be there... it's how a card like this would completely warp the draft environment. If I knew this existed in a draft, I would draft nothing but evasive creatures as often as I possibly could. A lot of drafts, then, would become "How many Spiked Clubs did you draft?" and "How well can you block evasive creatures?"
Well, the club itself can't deal damage :)
But assuming you fix that - yes; very.
How 'bout now? Overpowered?
Oh; odd. I thought they would.
Suggest making it rare then; for it's nichness.
Nice! A Compulsion that functions from the graveyard, and a Merfolk Looter in play.
0-power critters won't do much, since they don't count as "dealing combat damage" if they deal 0.
This seems fine. Most mill-themed one-drops don't do much (Merrow Witsniper anyone?). This at least has potential to be useful against people gaining lots of life, or hiding behind Worship.
The way Wizards have done it recently is to give Bonesplitter some random occasional benefit to make up for the third mana. Darksteel Axe, Silver-Inlaid Dagger, Trusty Machete.
So yes, this is fine; if you wanted you could take this opportunity to add some rather minor piece of set-specific flavour here.
Seems better to me. If you end up wanting to really push this you could try it at
, but I'd say stick at 
unless you have a need to make it much better.