2011-06-13 15:03:03:
Sorrow
commented on the cardset Isolation
6/13/2011
I unfortunately have limited computer access right now (and will for several months) so completion of this set is on hiatus until January of 2012.
Fascinating design. Wizards tend to shy away from lands that do this kind of thing. It'll usually give you the mana at times that aren't very useful, such as in the Combat Damage step. But nonetheless, this seems reasonable as a rare. It might be more likely to be something like a black enchantment.
Intriguing ability. Normally irrelevant, occasionally game-saving. But very odd on a common. It's only been seen before on rares - Timber Protector, Terra Eternal. I could see this as an uncommon though.
I had actually meant it to be when it enters the graveyard, but thanks for reminding me. I went with dies since it's the current wording, though I'm personally not fond of it.
Hm. I see what you're going for. I don't think the wording you have is too bad, really. You might want to make the last sentence start "The chosen player" rather than "That player".
6/13/2011 I unfortunately have limited computer access right now (and will for several months) so completion of this set is on hiatus until January of 2012.
Yeah, enchantment would be a bit more reasonable, but I felt I needed to make another special land for the WBR group since the other groups had more.
Fascinating design. Wizards tend to shy away from lands that do this kind of thing. It'll usually give you the mana at times that aren't very useful, such as in the Combat Damage step. But nonetheless, this seems reasonable as a rare. It might be more likely to be something like a black enchantment.
Intriguing ability. Normally irrelevant, occasionally game-saving. But very odd on a common. It's only been seen before on rares - Timber Protector, Terra Eternal. I could see this as an uncommon though.
I had actually meant it to be when it enters the graveyard, but thanks for reminding me. I went with dies since it's the current wording, though I'm personally not fond of it.
I think the text is missing "ETBs". I think it should be "When ~ ETBs, return target Zombie creature card from your graveyard...".
Thanks
Hm. I see what you're going for. I don't think the wording you have is too bad, really. You might want to make the last sentence start "The chosen player" rather than "That player".
Wording help?