2011-02-27 00:54:48:
wolfer
commented on the cardset Rallikar
I think most of your wary cards are underpowered. You need to have more ways to enable it, and the bonuses you get when you satisfy it need to be a bit bigger. It's also possible you may want to reduce the number to just 2.
I'm pretty sure if you have this and two other creatures, you can just attack with them all. The defender only kicks back in once the serpent is already attacking, so it won't matter.
Vedalken Entrancer but a bit more awkward. Seeing as you are bringing Vedalken back (I think, if the case you misspelled it) I don't see why you don't just reprint the entrancer.
I like this card, especially with the Wary mechanic. Do note though, that blue vigilance never really made it out of Planar Chaos. I think it should become a regular thing, but there's probably a good reason why it isn't.
This is fine, but it's weak. It compares pretty unfavorably to Dispel.
Not every card needs to be good, and it's fine as a flavorful common. If you want to spice it up, let it counter activated abilities too, but then you'd have to make it an uncommon.
I think you really need to consider how much the flying really matters. If the set had a p/t boosting aura theme, it'd be ok, but it doesn't like like that's the case.
There's nothing wrong with just reprinting Thought Courier/Merfolk Looter.
Alternative flavor text: "No, I don't really care much for deception. And enchantments are right out!"
Even at uncommon I think it's a bit too good. Mind Springing and milling them at the same time is ridiculous. Should probably be a rare.
There's no way this can stay common.
Fixed.
I think most of your wary cards are underpowered. You need to have more ways to enable it, and the bonuses you get when you satisfy it need to be a bit bigger. It's also possible you may want to reduce the number to just 2.
This is one of the better Wary cards you have, and makes me think the mechanic can be compelling when executed correctly.
I'm pretty sure if you have this and two other creatures, you can just attack with them all. The defender only kicks back in once the serpent is already attacking, so it won't matter.
Probably not the best card to put wary on.
Vedalken Entrancer but a bit more awkward. Seeing as you are bringing Vedalken back (I think, if the case you misspelled it) I don't see why you don't just reprint the entrancer.
Memory Lapse + Remand. This card is absurdly good, and should cost 1UU or 2U.
I like this card, especially with the Wary mechanic. Do note though, that blue vigilance never really made it out of Planar Chaos. I think it should become a regular thing, but there's probably a good reason why it isn't.
This is fine, but it's weak. It compares pretty unfavorably to Dispel.
Not every card needs to be good, and it's fine as a flavorful common. If you want to spice it up, let it counter activated abilities too, but then you'd have to make it an uncommon.
I think you really need to consider how much the flying really matters. If the set had a p/t boosting aura theme, it'd be ok, but it doesn't like like that's the case.
There's nothing wrong with just reprinting Thought Courier/Merfolk Looter.
This could cost XUUU or X1UU. Also, it should be a rare.