Ugh. Healing Salve made worse both by not being a viable combat trick AND forcing you to shuffle.

Well, Reminisce / Feldon's Cane are things people occasionally spend a card slot on. This is like that but getting another "benefit" too. Actually, what this is most like is Elixir of Immortality.

All good points. I'm aiming for color centered ways to retrieve your graveyard. Aiming to keep this a common is there anything that should be tweaked on it?

The problem is commons generally need to be useful in limited. And recycling your graveyard really isn't relevant in limited normally. But this set might be different: what is it about the set that's making you look for ways to get back graveyard cards?

This is likely to go in a set with heavy mill for blue and stealing things from graveyards in black

Examined in a vacuum, I really this. I think it could all be on one line tho, formatting purposes.

Yeah you're right it could. Fixing now.