I know "exile matters" but it's still less common that casting a creature. To really make exile a theme of the set, I say be aggressive, and cost this at 1, instead of 2.

Kind of like Confessor? I really liked that card back in Odyssey. Ran him in a deck just as an incidental one drop. Later, I wathced as he answered Upheaval followed by Psychatog. I dropped a Plains then Conservator, and suddenly my opponent couldn't kill me with a Psychotog? What the heck?

Anyhow, I'm off on a tangent. I know there's the potential for this to be a little nuts, but I agree, it should cost . Probably better to go with the natural casting cost.

@jmgariepy I was actually thinking of Soul Warden when I designed this card, but you're right, the standard for this kind of ability on a 1/1 is so I'll change it.