So basically i noticed that an initial comment is white, while others are pink or whatever

but i moved a few cards over and the pink things became white and dont tell anyone i said that it sounds bad....

anyway just not sure why that happened...

see? pink.

edit: if i moved it between sets it wouldnt be

This is the concept of "unaddressed comments". Waayy back when I was designing the site, I had the idea that people would want to keep certain comments as "todo" items, things that they want to act on. Like "Don't you think this needs to be better in combat?" or "Playtesting shows this is too confusing: simplify." The pink-highlighted comments are "unaddressed".

For any given cardset, only that cardset's owners/admins get to see which cardsets are marked as unaddressed: other users just see every comment as white. On a cardset you own/administer, each comment has a button above it to toggle its "unaddressed" status (it'll look like or ). Plus, in the big green/blue/red box at the top of each page that includes links like "Cardlist" or "Booster" or "Recent activity", for cardset owners there's a third line that includes "Add details page" and "Cardset options": that also includes "Unaddressed". This is a list of all the comments that are marked pink on that cardset - again, only visible to the cardset owner/admin.

If you decide you don't want to use the unaddressed status (I think most people don't use it), you can edit your cardset's options to change "Enable comment addressing" and "Default comment state".

Feedback: I'm using that system vigorously, so I'm happy it is in place.

My only gripe is that I cannot make the addressed/unadressed state visible to non-admins, because my entire process is based around collecting feedback and after a while getting back to it and it would be nice to let commenters know whether I'm still going to come back to their input.

Uh? I'm not admin of this set; and I see the unaddressed state of your above comment? I do see the toggle option, though. It also seems to work for me on, say, your set "Xerex, The Planar Labyrinth"

I also like this system; it's vbery helpful for me on my less-active sets to go back and collate a bunch of comments in one go next time I go back to give the set some more love. Though personally I tend to use the yellow-highlight option for my own todo-list.

Ah, OK, it looks like the unaddressed state is visible to anyone who has permissions to create cards in a set. Which is every signed-in user, for this set, and for Xerex, among others.