I definitely agree a 3/3 flier is significantly better than a 2/3 flier, I'm just saying that this card is a lot closer to reasonable than it was claimed to be.

Everything in this set is in constant flux so it's possible this card ends up being uncommon or not in the set at all. I mostly put it where it is so that it wasn't strictly better or worse than Nephalia Seakite or Faerie Invaders, two similar cards. It could probably at least cost .

Looking at gatherer, common gets 3/3 flying with upside, but usually for 5 mana or 4 mana with two colours. 5 mana would certainly be fine; 4 mana wouldn't be game breaking but would be very unusual. I do think the extra points of P/T matter -- at limited, one 3/3 with evasion can be significantly better than a 3/2 or a 2/3.

It's definitely fine at uncommon; uncommon gets much bigger things.

It sure is strong but I hardly think it's "above uncommon". Nephalia Seakite trades 1 point of power for always having flash and is fine at common. Even if this was too powerful for common, which it might be, it would make a perfectly acceptable uncommon.

A common 3/3 flying for that if another one is in play "which seems easy since they are common" It has flash aswell? This is to good even for an Uncommon imo. First pick any day.

Thanks, I was wondering how to correctly word this.

Unfortunately, I think this is useless as worded, since it only functions on the battlefield. I believe it needs to read "As long as you control a Vedalken, you may cast ~ as though it had flash."

I feel like there needs to be at least some soft answers to delve available. It's possible this effect ends up being unnecessary in which case it can change.

A nice and fairly strong graveyard hoser. Thraben Heretic is more splashable but slower. Does this set want strong graveyard hosing at common?

derp, yes

Should this be "if enchanted creature doesn't have a shield counter on it"?