[Card Dump] Tahazzar's Designs: Cardlist | Visual spoiler | Export | Booster | Comments | Search | Recent activity
Mechanics

CardName: Positive Karma Cost: 3W Type: Enchantment Pow/Tgh: / Rules Text: {1}, Exile any number of cards face down from your hand, from your graveyard, and/or from the top of your library: You gain life equal to the number of cards exiled this way until Positive Karma leaves the battlefield. (When it leaves the battlefield, you lose all that life.) Flavour Text: Set/Rarity: [Card Dump] Tahazzar's Designs Mythic

Positive Karma
{3}{w}
 
 M 
Enchantment
{1}, Exile any number of cards face down from your hand, from your graveyard, and/or from the top of your library: You gain life equal to the number of cards exiled this way until Positive Karma leaves the battlefield. (When it leaves the battlefield, you lose all that life.)
Illus. Nellor (nello shep) | DeviantArt.com
Updated on 22 May 2018 by Tahazzar

History: [-]

2018-05-20 12:49:44: Tahazzar created the card Positive Karma

Isn't this an instant win combo with Lab Maniac or Barren Glory or some other degenerate combo which involves putting things on the bottom of your library?

A lot of things combo with Laboratory Maniac. It doesn't really combo well with Barren Glory since it doesn't get things off the table, which is the tough part of the Glory.

Not sure what the 'degenerate combo which involves putting things on the bottom of your library' is. You'd still have to exile the rest of your library just to play that card over and over. The end result would need to be on par with Eternal Dominion for it to be worth it (in a strictly Spike-y way of 'worth it'.)

Which isn't to say the card isn't Bonkers T. Bobcat. Since most games use less than 30 cards out of a 60 card deck, this card roughly represents a gain of 40 life for {4}{w} with few negative ramifications (since you would only gain the life if you were about to die.) The card is admittedly trickier if your opponent has a Demystify ready... but you could probably sneak 20 life out of this card before it goes to the bin without worrying too much about being decked.

I'd say "Gain 1 life for every two cards" but people don't like 'drawback' mythics that are balanced. Tricky problem.

2018-05-21 05:16:49: Tahazzar edited Positive Karma:

-{1} to mana cost; +{1} to activation; ... until ~ leaves play

2018-05-21 05:21:53: Tahazzar edited Positive Karma:

minor reminder text edit

I've personally been thinking about the subset of cards with 'Whenever you gain life' with which this is quite bonkers with. Hence the edits. I might have erred on the side of too much caution with the "until ~ LTB" clause.

Gaining ~40 life for {4}{w} doesn't sound that impressive when you think about it competitively. Life gain does have the problem of stretching out games though.

Lab Maniac has always been questionable in multiple ways. In this case, I would say you are still better of with Leveler and especially with Puresight Merrow + Paradise Mantle. Regardless, if Maniac were to be truly problematic, I would say the issues there lie with the design of Maniac more so than with this card.

Yeah, life gain from a strictly competitive point of view is weird. I think I remember Wizards doing an informal questionnaire of pro-tour players, asking how much life gain is necessary for them to think about playing a one mana instant that only gained life. Results varied, but I think the average reasonable starting point was 8... which is clearly not Magic baseline.

Personally speaking, I prefer to pretend that the current life gain model that we use is the right one. Mostly, because I assume Wizards has playtested other options, and I have not. But I definitely understand the desire to slide the life gain scale up to a more competitive level. As long as you're okay with the idea that playing this card on round 5 demolishes red burn and suicide black. Not every fake Magic set needs to have the same metagame parameters.

Add your comments:


(formatting help)
Enter mana symbols like this: {2}{U}{U/R}{PR}, {T} becomes {2}{u}{u/r}{pr}, {t}
You can use Markdown such as _italic_, **bold**, ## headings ##
Link to [[[Official Magic card]]] or (((Card in Multiverse)))
Include [[image of official card]] or ((image or mockup of card in Multiverse))
Make hyperlinks like this: [text to show](destination url)
What is this card's power? Hollowhenge Beast
(Signed-in users don't get captchas and can edit their comments)