[Democracy: Bottom-up Set]: Cardlist | Visual spoiler | Export | Booster | Comments | Search | Recent activity

CardName: Vote 1 - Top-down or Bottom-up? Cost: Type: Vote Pow/Tgh: / Rules Text: The direction for a set is decided on by whether it is governed by Story/Theme (top-down) or whether Mechanics play a bigger part. Examples of a top-down set: Theros Examples of a bottom-up set: Ravnica Flavour Text: Vote ends 28 March 2014. Put votes in comments. Set/Rarity: [Democracy: Bottom-up Set] None

Vote 1 - Top-down or Bottom-up?
 
Vote
The direction for a set is decided on by whether it is governed by Story/Theme (top-down) or whether Mechanics play a bigger part.
Examples of a top-down set: Theros
Examples of a bottom-up set: Ravnica
Vote ends 28 March 2014. Put votes in comments.
Expand text
Updated on 20 Mar 2014 by cmeister2

Code: V01

History: [-]

2014-03-20 14:18:10: cmeister2 created the card Vote 1 - Top-down or Bottom-up?
2014-03-20 14:20:13: cmeister2 edited Vote 1 - Top-down or Bottom-up?
2014-03-20 14:23:34: cmeister2 edited Vote 1 - Top-down or Bottom-up?:

Ravnica was a bottom-up set, I'm reliably informed

on 20 Mar 2014 by Jack V:

I'm not sure how voting on everything will go, but I vote "Top-down".

on 20 Mar 2014 by amuseum:

i prefer back-front. never been a face-to-face person.

if thats not valid choice then bottom up

on 20 Mar 2014 by Link:

Yes, you've always seemed like someone who wouldn't get along well face-to-face. :-P
I vote for bottom-up.

on 20 Mar 2014 by Alex:

Example of a back-front set: Mirroria :)

on 20 Mar 2014 by Link:

Hahahaha.

on 20 Mar 2014 by amuseum:

oh Alex, you're so kinky. so you design the back side first? and thus, this card is born: Chaos Spatula

on 20 Mar 2014 by cmeister2:

I vote for bottom-up; let's make some mechanics :)

on 21 Mar 2014 by jmgariepy:

Can I vote for doing the Time Warp, and taking a step to the left, then a jump to the right?

No? Then Top, immediately followed by Bottoms-up. I rarely stay at the top, but it often sets up the idea. I'm not sure that was an option, either. Hmm.

Ah, put me down once for both. I do both. Often at the same time.

on 21 Mar 2014 by Circeus:

Bottoms up.

on 21 Mar 2014 by Link:

All sets have some elements of both.

on 21 Mar 2014 by amuseum:

one thing for sure, i don't want Yet Another Ravnica Block (YARB)

on 21 Mar 2014 by Circeus:

Mostly because so many of them are floating around. People REALLY REALLY liked Ravnica XD

on 21 Mar 2014 by Vitenka:

I've yet to figure out why. I say top down; it's what I'm worst at.

on 22 Mar 2014 by Link:

Current Tally:
Top-down: 2
Bottom-up: 4

I doubt we'll get many more votes, but I could be wrong.

on 24 Mar 2014 by cmeister2:

I wanted to give people a chance to respond; if it looks like this is all the votes we're going to get, I might pull forward the voting date to, say, Wednesday.

on 25 Mar 2014 by amuseum:

i'd vote top-down if it was a megablock called Multiverse Showdown where it's a free-for-all with Dominaria vs Phyrexia vs Ravnica vs Eldrazi vs Innistrad

on 26 Mar 2014 by cmeister2:

Ok, it's looking like bottom up is going to win this, and now it's Wednesday, so I'm calling it.

Add your comments:


(formatting help)
Enter mana symbols like this: {2}{U}{U/R}{PR}, {T} becomes {2}{u}{u/r}{pr}, {t}
You can use Markdown such as _italic_, **bold**, ## headings ##
Link to [[[Official Magic card]]] or (((Card in Multiverse)))
Include [[image of official card]] or ((image or mockup of card in Multiverse))
Make hyperlinks like this: [text to show](destination url)
How much damage does this card deal? Lava Axe
(Signed-in users don't get captchas and can edit their comments)