Multiverse: Faith vs Science DD challenge: Recent Activity

2015-09-04 17:31:35: CasualR commented on Honored Missionary

I think the Cleric part is fine. I think the Human part should go.

2015-09-04 17:30:24: CasualR commented on Cogwork Bull

It is more of a word of caution. I accidentally had the inline image. I figured the most amusing one would serve as an example of what not to do. So far nothing horrible has happened.

2015-09-04 17:27:37: CasualR commented on Ritual Combat

No. The idea was for it to just be a Convoke fight spell. That is off the table. I am open to iterations.

2015-09-04 15:30:07: Charlie Grant commented on Honored Missionary

The flavor was that he is replaced by the convert he makes as a missionary.

2015-09-04 15:29:07: Charlie Grant commented on Modular Thopter

Modular is not evergreen.

2015-09-04 15:20:35: SecretInfiltrator commented on Wurmcoil Prototype

Took me quite a while to realize this triggers twice - I expect it on noncreature artifacts, but on creatures it is less automatically expected.

Can we do something about this? Maybe make it an ability word (since the faith deck currently has two new named mechanics as well)?

2015-09-04 15:09:03: SecretInfiltrator commented on Yanthar, High Elementalist

I personally am not a fan of designing the important legendary mythic rare creature as basically a glorified enchantment.

2015-09-04 15:06:33: SecretInfiltrator edited Yanthar, High Elementalist:

added "nontoken"

2015-09-04 14:51:09: SecretInfiltrator commented on Pilgrim's Journey

This card is in a card slot that no longer exists.

2015-09-04 14:48:47: SecretInfiltrator commented on Graceful Ascetic

Does this card actually belong into this deck? Faith is about collecting creatures and ramping to the seven mana to pray. How does this card add to the central theme of the deck?

2015-09-04 14:46:50: SecretInfiltrator commented on Knight of the Faith

Common 3/4s and 2/4s for 4W: Unseemly Zealot, Harbinger of Avacyn, Knight of the Faith. Also similar Loxodon Faithful.

This is one of two cards from the list that has pray.

2015-09-04 14:46:44: SecretInfiltrator commented on Harbinger of Avacyn

Common 3/4s and 2/4s for 4W: Unseemly Zealot, Harbinger of Avacyn, Knight of the Faith. Also similar Loxodon Faithful.

This is one of two cards from the list that has pray.

2015-09-04 14:46:18: SecretInfiltrator commented on Unseemly Zealot

Common 3/4s and 2/4s for 4W: Unseemly Zealot, Harbinger of Avacyn, Knight of the Faith. Also similar Loxodon Faithful.

2015-09-04 14:46:08: SecretInfiltrator commented on Loxodon Faithful

Common 3/4s and 2/4s for 4W: Unseemly Zealot, Harbinger of Avacyn, Knight of the Faith are all similar to this.

2015-09-04 14:35:33: SecretInfiltrator edited Otherworldly Guidance:

added "until end of turn" and nonfunctional changes.

2015-09-04 14:17:47: SecretInfiltrator commented on Honored Missionary

Any reason the token should be Human Cleric? Cleric seems fine and in green we have quite a diversity of believers (Rhox, Elf, Centaur).

Do you just want to make faith seem xenophobic? I don't think that's a message we want.

2015-09-04 14:00:00: SecretInfiltrator commented on Modular Thopter

Reading the cardname again... maybe featuring modular would not be a bad idea for the deck - it allows for some simple unified death triggers.

2015-09-04 13:57:47: SecretInfiltrator edited Modular Thopter:

was: artifact with P/T; now: artifact creature

2015-09-04 13:37:41: SecretInfiltrator commented on Ogre Inventor

Ogre Inventor and Cogwork Bull currently are very similar: 5-6 mana 4/3s with a tinker effect that deals 3-4 damage to the opponent.

I think we can diversify a bit.

2015-09-04 13:37:17: SecretInfiltrator commented on Cogwork Bull

Ogre Inventor and Cogwork Bull currently are very similar: 5-6 mana 4/3s with a tinker effect that deals 3-4 damage to the opponent.

I think we can diversify a bit.

p.s.: Inline card images are a terrible idea, not a 'word of wisdom'.

2015-09-04 13:29:57: SecretInfiltrator commented on Autonomous Thrasher

This is so close to metalcraft that I would consider making the change to have a cameo mechanic - IIRC the faith deck has a cameo mechanic as well.

2015-09-04 13:26:12: SecretInfiltrator edited Majestic Pridebeast:

common slot, should probably be common, was: none

2015-09-04 12:43:21: SecretInfiltrator edited Woodland Monastery:

I dislike how empty card slot looks in the set, so check out this land as food for thought.

2015-09-04 12:25:57: SecretInfiltrator commented on Elvish Purist

Thinking about it some more the flash is not an integral part of the design.

2015-09-04 11:57:32: SecretInfiltrator commented on Ritual Combat

Red Flag for word count at common.

Time to Feed actually would be a really cool card to functionally reprint in this set considering Parish Guardian.

Is there really a point to have the fight spell in this set to be exactly this?

2015-09-04 11:53:48: SecretInfiltrator commented on Sylvan Spiritualist

Red Flag for word count at common - even without the activated mana ability.

2015-09-03 01:15:52: Doombringer edited Cogwork Bull:

+1 power

2015-09-02 18:08:58: CasualR commented on Cogwork Bull

At 5R, I'd probably make it a 5/3. I think two creatures is probably the sweet spot for a common.

2015-09-01 19:40:43: SecretInfiltrator commented on Arch Cathedral

Maybe this could be closer to Selesnya Evangel.

" {2} , {t} , Tap two untapped creatures you control: Put a 1/1 white Cleric creature token onto the battlefield."?

2015-09-01 19:38:43: Charlie Grant edited Cogwork Bull