Multiverse: Errol Clegg EDH: Recent Activity

2016-10-29 19:58:02: lklklk124 edited a card

2016-10-29 19:57:50: lklklk124 edited a card

2016-10-29 19:57:12: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Quartermaster

2016-10-29 19:56:33: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Treasurer

2016-10-29 19:56:05: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Quartermaster

2016-10-29 19:55:51: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Quartermaster

2016-10-29 19:33:16: lklklk124 edited Errol Clegg, "Privateer"

2016-10-29 19:31:44: lklklk124 edited Stormbourne Mystic

2016-10-29 19:30:15: lklklk124 edited Hoist the Jolly Roger

2016-10-29 19:29:25: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Quartermaster

2016-10-29 19:22:48: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Raidleader

2016-10-29 19:21:19: Mal commented on Clegg's Watchman

This card is blue.

Just make it blue.

2016-10-29 19:21:16: lklklk124 edited Stormbourne Mystic

2016-10-29 19:16:49: Mal commented on Kidnap for Ransom

This definitely reads like a hostage situation, but a less confusing wording for this should be something like

"At the beginning of your upkeep, choose a creature and a noncreature permanent with the same controller. Gain control of one of those permanents of that player's choice."

As its worded right now the opposing player can give you another player's permanent that you choose.

2016-10-29 19:14:50: lklklk124 edited Ship's Cannon

2016-10-29 19:14:22: lklklk124 edited Ship's Cannon

2016-10-29 19:13:42: lklklk124 edited Clegg's Watchman

2016-10-29 19:12:29: Mal commented on a card

2016-10-29 19:11:02: lklklk124 edited a card

2016-10-29 19:10:27: Mal commented on Ship's Cannon

I assume this should read " {t} , Tap an untapped Pirate you control:..."

This also isn't black. I would highly suggest this costing a little more, like {4} .

2016-10-29 19:09:28: lklklk124 edited a card

2016-10-29 19:09:20: lklklk124 edited a card

2016-10-29 19:08:59: Mal commented on Clegg's Deckhand

Flagbearer effect is pretty old, but it was pretty solidly white back in the day. If you really want something that has this type of effect, I'd suggest riffing off of Imp's Mischief and Spellskite and making it something like

"Pay X life: Change the target of target spell with converted mana cost X or less to ~."

2/1 also feels like a better fit for the card's stats. It doesn't matter much in EDH other than chump blocking tiny dudes, but the amount of utility even an ability like the above would have is a fine tradeoff.

This should also be an uncommon or rare.

2016-10-29 19:08:52: lklklk124 edited Stormbourne Mystic

2016-10-29 19:08:13: lklklk124 edited Kidnap for Ransom

2016-10-29 19:05:07: Mal commented on Stormbourne Mystic

Sigiled Starfish is {1} {u} . The only other 1/3 for 1 is Permeating Mass, and this definitely isn't a Green card.

2016-10-29 19:04:07: Mal commented on Clegg's Raidleader

Why isn't this mono- {u} ?

2016-10-29 19:03:19: Mal commented on Clegg's First Mate

"Creature cards you own that aren't on the battlefield, creature spells you control, and creatures you control are Pirates in addition to their other types.

At the beginning of your end step, return target Pirate from your graveyard to your hand."

Very very powerful. This is basically Palace Siege on a stick, so maybe something like {3} {u} {b} for a 3/3 is more fair, if not 3/2. This is a combination of Xenograft and it, so {u} {b} actually works this time. I'd probably lean more towards {2} {u} {b} {b} if you're looking for something more unique.

2016-10-29 18:58:55: lklklk124 edited Kidnap for Ransom

2016-10-29 18:58:02: lklklk124 edited Kidnap for Ransom