Brainstormed Laws: - Casting a spell that targets a creature you control is against the law. - Casting spells during combat is against the law. - Casting two or more spells a turn is against the law. - Casting no spells is against the law. - Blocking creatures you control is against the law. - Transforming a permanent is against the law. - Activated an ability of an artifact or creature is against the law.

(((Consul Magistrate))) seems to overlap too much here

As an aside about the flavor of Justice, your opponent gaining 2 life doesn't feel like much of a punishment. It's the equivalent of stealing a loaf of bread, getting caught, and having the town clerk pay the baker while you eat your loaf at home.

I understand that not every mechanic has to ring perfectly with flavor. But I really like Justice, mostly because It's screaming with flavor. I would assume you guys would prefer that your swan dive is followed through with a perfect no-splash entry.

my headcanon was that this is someone who gets rewarded for reporting crime.

I'll change the name to make that more apparent.