Multiverse: Reckoning: Recent Activity

2017-07-04 13:39:13: jmgariepy commented on Resonance Inhibitor

I don't know. That {7} made me smile. And it only effects instants and sorceries... and can be foiled by graveyard removal.

It could still be unfair, though. Is it more or less fair that Grafdigger's Cage? Is it trying to solve a potential runaway problem in your set, in the way that the Cage was trying to preemptively answer Zombie and Flashback decks before they became dominant?

2017-07-04 10:15:46: Vitenka commented on Resonance Inhibitor

Nice. Both its breakable symmetry (use permanents) and that eventually you can pay through it. I might suggest decreasing that 7 a bit, to make that hope a bit more plausible though.

2017-07-02 17:02:11: ttt3142 created the card Resonance Inhibitor

2017-07-02 16:00:57: ttt3142 edited Detritus Maul:

trample

2017-03-28 17:34:42: ttt3142 edited Lifeboat Ethicist

2017-03-28 17:33:37: ttt3142 commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

Long live Athreos, I guess.

2017-03-28 17:33:07: ttt3142 edited Lifeboat Ethicist

2017-03-28 11:14:42: Vitenka commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

Worded as it is, it's going to cause arguments. "I choose discard a card, no cards, nothing happens" "But you can't do that!" "But it would SAY if I couldn't do that."

i.e. rules may like it, but reality won't. Since it can be fixed, do.

But; uh; don't because that then becomes an absolutely terribly boring lock-down again.

2017-03-27 09:58:55: SecretInfiltrator commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

@Tahazzar: The rules don't agree with you. The creature's controller has to choose an action they can perform if able i. e. if they have a creature, but no cards, they have to choose the sacrifice option and vice versa.

It is only "unless" wording where on alternative is entirely optional (e. g. with your wording they could sacrifice the creature in response to the trigger and even if it was their only creature they wouldn't need to discard a card unless they chose to).

2017-03-27 09:14:22: Tahazzar commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

Oh, and this probably should say "sacrifices a creature unless he or she discards a card". Otherwise this doesn't do anything if the opponent has no cards in hand (except for the creature he or she casts), which IMO might be too weak (it does cost {3} {b} {b} after all).

2017-03-26 11:17:44: Tahazzar commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

It's strong but nothing overwhelming in terms of power level. IMO the real concern is that it can create a very unfun scenario.

The added discard clause is a fine fix.

2017-03-25 22:51:50: ttt3142 commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

Added the "discards a card" clause, so an opponent at least has a way to stick creatures onto the board. You're right though that this effect is very strong. It may still be too strong, but I'll leave it like this for now.

2017-03-25 22:49:04: ttt3142 edited Lifeboat Ethicist

2017-03-25 15:22:15: Tahazzar commented on Lifeboat Ethicist

That's just nasty. A {g} deck is pretty much just screwed if you can drop this while they have no or very few creatures. Closest card I can find is Tainted Aether. Sure, this might be more removable, but with Tainted you can always sac your land at least to get your fattie to stick on the board.

2017-03-24 23:11:55: ttt3142 created the card Lifeboat Ethicist

2017-03-18 01:35:57: ttt3142 edited Westminster Abbey

2017-03-17 22:47:30: ttt3142 created the card Westminster Abbey

2017-03-17 22:25:15: ttt3142 edited the details page Skeleton

2017-03-17 22:24:04: ttt3142 generated part of a set skeleton in Skeleton

2017-03-09 21:27:47: ttt3142 created the card Firebombing

2017-03-05 20:26:52: ttt3142 edited Icon of Fallen Ideals:

now taps

2017-03-05 09:03:40: Vitenka commented on Icon of Fallen Ideals

Humm. Like High Market/Animal Boneyard or Gutless Ghoul but better for tokens (and wors for really big creatures, but that will hardly ever matter), and every colour. So it feels too cheap to me.

Maybe price it at {4} as a more modern Life Chisel? While life-gain is usually weak; get enough of it and it is strong :) And 50 life is a win-condition now; so 8 creatures and 8 mana over as many turns as you like...

2017-03-05 02:15:59: ttt3142 created the card Icon of Fallen Ideals

2017-03-02 20:00:58: ttt3142 edited Detritus Maul

2017-03-02 19:02:13: ttt3142 moved the card Detritus Maul from Armageddon into Reckoning

2017-03-02 08:29:29: Vitenka commented on Rage Against the Machine

An improved Shatterstorm? Sign me up!

2017-03-02 04:30:18: ttt3142 edited Rage Against the Machine

2015-01-16 16:06:50: ttt3142 deleted the card Operation Final Moon from Reckoning

2015-01-16 12:14:32: Alex commented on a card

2015-01-16 06:42:17: ttt3142 edited a card:

Thoughts?