the type bar needs capitalization, and the text should be:
Enchanted creature gets +3/+3, gains flying and has "Whenever this creature attacks, tap all creatures defending player controls"
this is a very powerful effect, but it seems like this late in the game it might be more risk than it's worth you probs used Hideous Wish and other tutors to get cards, you likely arent playing this alone, its good enough to, but also synergises in life loss decks, and likely you are l;ow on life at this point. Still good, but in lots of games it might be like: oh i cast this. i have 5 life. concede because cant cast my grave titan
also now that i think of it, this, as an enchantment, should hardly cost 9... i'd probably lower it to 7, because by turn 9 it's really pointless to have any new statics, because right then you'd likely want some finisher or payout
so it could be a legendary sorcery / instant, which would make sense because only planeswalker can access the aether realm
Nice. As a mythic, you could make it more like one from the titan cycle: ie when etbs or attacks or dies, you may do x
my idea might be op, but this seems a little bit weaker than mythic. kind of rarish
this would go perfect with my blue-black horror archtypes, mind if I make a functional reprint?? Probably not at mythic anyway...
This seems a little weak for mythic slot
Seething Song adds two mana to your pool. This adds three. And Seething Song has a Gatherer rating of 4.474... so it's not like that's a bad card. It's potentially too good...
So, if I was to guess, I would say this was equivalent to a spectacular four casting cost spell. Kind of like a land that cast an uncounterable Fact or Fiction when it hit the table.
Very nice card. Might be a bit more expensive than it needs to be, it seems like a logical cost, but my mind says it could be cheaper. maybe just 8 mana?
Phoenixes cannot be blue, i don't think making it an illusion allows that to be okay.
Ignoring the color flaw: the text could be simplified to something like:
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, you may return Phantom Phoenix from your graveyard to the battlefield.
OR if that is too strong
Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, you may return Phantom Phoenix from your graveyard to your hand.
the way you have it now is over complicated and adding a lot of weird steps when you really dont have to
i think you might need a comma between land card and you may
i think you need a comma between dies and you may
Exile each creature, each opponent loses X life and you gain X life, where X is the number of creatures exiled this way
i dont know if that rules text is perfectly grammatical
the type bar needs capitalization, and the text should be: Enchanted creature gets +3/+3, gains flying and has "Whenever this creature attacks, tap all creatures defending player controls"
technicality: whenever you cast another spell, do x?
this is a very powerful effect, but it seems like this late in the game it might be more risk than it's worth you probs used Hideous Wish and other tutors to get cards, you likely arent playing this alone, its good enough to, but also synergises in life loss decks, and likely you are l;ow on life at this point. Still good, but in lots of games it might be like: oh i cast this. i have 5 life. concede because cant cast my grave titan
also now that i think of it, this, as an enchantment, should hardly cost 9... i'd probably lower it to 7, because by turn 9 it's really pointless to have any new statics, because right then you'd likely want some finisher or payout
so it could be a legendary sorcery / instant, which would make sense because only planeswalker can access the aether realm
thanx
Nice. As a mythic, you could make it more like one from the titan cycle: ie when etbs or attacks or dies, you may do x my idea might be op, but this seems a little bit weaker than mythic. kind of rarish
go ahead, your set probably needs a card to head the horror archtype
this would go perfect with my blue-black horror archtypes, mind if I make a functional reprint?? Probably not at mythic anyway... This seems a little weak for mythic slot
less ramp
you're right, i will lower the amount of mana it adds to
Seething Song adds two mana to your pool. This adds three. And Seething Song has a Gatherer rating of 4.474... so it's not like that's a bad card. It's potentially too good...
So, if I was to guess, I would say this was equivalent to a spectacular four casting cost spell. Kind of like a land that cast an uncounterable Fact or Fiction when it hit the table.
Almost. I mean, it's not quite, because it only makes red, and uses your land drop. But it's still fairly obviously far too good.
I think this breaks all the rules about lands. seems very OP!
It's basically a free 3 mana on turn 1, this is basically a black lotus.
Very nice card. Might be a bit more expensive than it needs to be, it seems like a logical cost, but my mind says it could be cheaper. maybe just 8 mana?
Phoenixes cannot be blue, i don't think making it an illusion allows that to be okay.
Ignoring the color flaw: the text could be simplified to something like: Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, you may return Phantom Phoenix from your graveyard to the battlefield. OR if that is too strong Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, you may return Phantom Phoenix from your graveyard to your hand.
the way you have it now is over complicated and adding a lot of weird steps when you really dont have to
thanks, i might put it up to 6 cmc
That might need to be a bit more CMC, but i'm no expert...
Also that flavor text lines up astonishingly with blue philosophy